Day 05 - Immunity Challenge #2

Also, why do we keep proceeding with the same number of tribe members? That defeats the purpose. I thought if One tribe has 4 and one has 2 it's still fair because it goes by eliminating members? There's no way to decide a winner this way.

Okay, no, I appologize if there is a freeze on the forums, although I can almost guarantee there wasn't since I'm paying out the proverbial anus for the fastest server I can get... but if there would have been it's considered part of the challenge and just bad luck.

Ami, you're out of the challenge. Mia please name someone else to join Ami on the bench.

If Ami had it 19 seconds like Chris said, I fail to see how that's 20 seconds.

Postby Kim » Tue Nov 13, 2012 4:27:31 am
Postby Ami » Tue Nov 13, 2012 4:27:56 am

Sorry Mia, that's 25 seconds. Chris is living in the the year 2059, don't mind him.

I'm still in though, right? :P

Sadness

I think you're sitting out members as an idol clue penalty Mia. We had two people take a clue and you had three.

Okay, I accept that. I didn't bother to check the time myself.

But I'm super confused on the rules. If Ami is out, why do I have to sit someone else out? I figured we would proceed 6/5 and whoever loses all members first loses.

I think you're sitting out members as an idol clue penalty Mia. We had two people take a clue and you had three.

Reason Tom said Mia

Mia, Ami did take too long.

Not to intrude on your decision, but maybe John should sit out.

You really should have told us this before the first round.

Okay, I accept that. I didn't bother to check the time myself.

But I'm super confused on the rules. If Ami is out, why do I have to sit someone else out? I figured we would proceed 6/5 and whoever loses all members first loses.

Because apparently 3 people from our tribe took an idol clue.

chris u should sit out for badmouthing your own tribe

...especially since I asked. Why let everyone participate only to screw us on the second round?

Wouldn't a more fair penalty be less time, like 18 seconds or something?

if not, I'll stop arguing, but I want to clear this up.

Yes we should have and I appologize for that. We got lost in the shuffle of Tribal Council and Challenges all at once.

There's a learning curve for hosts, but luckily you brought it to our attention before it was too late, so thank you Mia :)

I have to pee.

...especially since I asked. Why let everyone participate only to screw us on the second round?

Wouldn't a more fair penalty be less time, like 18 seconds or something?

Just follow the rules given Mia

I have to sleep :(

...especially since I asked. Why let everyone participate only to screw us on the second round?

Wouldn't a more fair penalty be less time, like 18 seconds or something?

She has a point!

Personally I think there should be no time limit. If someone has the tamale for 30 seconds it's their own stupid fault.