On-going Tribal Council Commentary!

Well Mia you kind of fucked up that first challenge so everyone really didn't like you, especially with you targeting Brook and him having his hands everywhere.

I also did the same Tom.

How did I fuck up the first one? That was John...

Guys, I think we should all agree that NOBODY fucked up the first challenge more than Gregg

He must be talking about Hot Tamale...

But in my defense, Brenda really did distract me. I saw her post and then Brook/Jo's new posts got ignored by my page refresh.

Anyone want to own up to my rankings? I assume that was John/Brook/Chad, but who knows.

I was actually shocked by your rankings Mia. I ranked you a lot higher than you appeared on those things. Especially in challenges. I couldn't BELIEVE I was ahead of you.

LOVE your question to BJ, Chad.

*thought Lisa was responding to my question* I was like omg Lisa answered first?? ... :P

Well Mia you kind of fucked up that first challenge so everyone really didn't like you, especially with you targeting Brook and him having his hands everywhere.

I also did the same Tom.

Wut? Mia did awesome at the first challenge.

Chris... I'm not exactly sure what you told Mia after the swap or what you thought everyone was thinking, but the only one who was really anti-Mia was Brook and YOU. John, Ami, and I had talked and we were all like no freaking way are we getting rid of Mia over Dolly or Lisa. That would be completely retarded. I thought she was perfect to take to the merge too because all the Choros were so agitated with her antics at Hot Tamale I thought the chance of them trying to align with her and her flipping on us were minimal. I have no idea what you came up with and told her, but the anti-Mia stuff was only for like the first two days we got here. After that, ALL of us wanted to keep her. Except Brook. And I thought you....

Well Mia you kind of fucked up that first challenge so everyone really didn't like you, especially with you targeting Brook and him having his hands everywhere.

I also did the same Tom.

How did I fuck up the first one? That was John...

Guys, I think we should all agree that NOBODY fucked up the first challenge more than Gregg

I have no idea what Gregg did..... but John had to have come pretty fucking close. The whole thing was solved and he just had to put it together. It was a fucking debacle. He switched leadership to Ami so she could post the answer. Or else we would have lost. There was no way he was getting that.

Well Mia you kind of fucked up that first challenge so everyone really didn't like you, especially with you targeting Brook and him having his hands everywhere.

I also did the same Tom.

How did I fuck up the first one? That was John...

Guys, I think we should all agree that NOBODY fucked up the first challenge more than Gregg

Really the leader who put me in the position to where I was gonna have to solve a puzzle when I said twice in our team forum I suck at puzzles would be edited as the reason we lost if this was a tv show.

Guys, I think we should all agree that NOBODY fucked up the first challenge more than Gregg

Really the leader who put me in the position to where I was gonna have to solve a puzzle when I said twice in our team forum I suck at puzzles would be edited as the reason we lost if this was a tv show.

Psshhhh, you will be SO OTTN in Episode 1 whenever this fanfic gets written (it's gotta get written guys, I wanna see my CPP turned CPNN edit in action ) but it will just surprise the audience even more when you turn into the strategic leading force of NuGuatuso.

Guys, I think we should all agree that NOBODY fucked up the first challenge more than Gregg

Really the leader who put me in the position to where I was gonna have to solve a puzzle when I said twice in our team forum I suck at puzzles would be edited as the reason we lost if this was a tv show.

Psshhhh, you will be SO OTTN in Episode 1 whenever this fanfic gets written (it's gotta get written guys, I wanna see my CPP turned CPNN edit in action ) but it will just surprise the audience even more when you turn into the strategic leading force of NuGuatuso.

He was not the strategic leading force of nuGuatuso. He was an assclown. That we thought we could pick up because it was clear that everyone on Chorotega didn't like him. But it turned out he was a lying assclown.

What exactly did Gregg do during that challenge? Is he really color blind? Why didn't Caryn help him with it if he couldn't do it?

John was a total fucking trainwreck when he had to put the four puzzles together and we were all screaming at him JOHN GIVE UP YOUR LEADER ROLE so someone else could post it. We would have had it done in 30 minutes easily if he was listening to us.

Well Mia you kind of fucked up that first challenge so everyone really didn't like you, especially with you targeting Brook and him having his hands everywhere.

I also did the same Tom.

Wut? Mia did awesome at the first challenge.

Chris... I'm not exactly sure what you told Mia after the swap or what you thought everyone was thinking, but the only one who was really anti-Mia was Brook and YOU. John, Ami, and I had talked and we were all like no freaking way are we getting rid of Mia over Dolly or Lisa. That would be completely retarded. I thought she was perfect to take to the merge too because all the Choros were so agitated with her antics at Hot Tamale I thought the chance of them trying to align with her and her flipping on us were minimal. I have no idea what you came up with and told her, but the anti-Mia stuff was only for like the first two days we got here. After that, ALL of us wanted to keep her. Except Brook. And I thought you....

I'm still finding it hard to believe that Chris, who was a demanding mess since before the swap actually tried to make me out to be the bad guy when we GOT swapped. I was incredibly open and came clean about the alliance I had with John/Chad/Brook because it was fucking DONE. And if I had went pre-merge at the hands of Chris telling Mia I was like out to get her? That would have been too fucked up to even comprehend

He was not the strategic leading force of nuGuatuso. He was an assclown. That we thought we could pick up because it was clear that everyone on Chorotega didn't like him. But it turned out he was a lying assclown.

What exactly did Gregg do during that challenge? Is he really color blind? Why didn't Caryn help him with it if he couldn't do it?

John was a total fucking trainwreck when he had to put the four puzzles together and we were all screaming at him JOHN GIVE UP YOUR LEADER ROLE so someone else could post it. We would have had it done in 30 minutes easily if he was listening to us.

I think it took a collective of 15-18 minutes for us four to post the pieces (Me, Chris, Brook then Chad)....THEN he took just over 30 minutes until he finally gave the leadership to me. That memory still upsets me.

[quote="Chad"]

He was not the strategic leading force of nuGuatuso. He was an assclown. That we thought we could pick up because it was clear that everyone on Chorotega didn't like him. But it turned out he was a lying assclown.


I was in 3 seperate alliances of the tribe and was always dictating the boots on NuGuatuso and was the only person never on the minority of the vote. Even after I had shown I was disloyal I created enough friction that even when I had become a trainwreck you and Brook and Ibe-Jolanda all never decided to just come together and vote me out at the f5.

Well Mia you kind of fucked up that first challenge so everyone really didn't like you, especially with you targeting Brook and him having his hands everywhere.

I also did the same Tom.

Wut? Mia did awesome at the first challenge.

Chris... I'm not exactly sure what you told Mia after the swap or what you thought everyone was thinking, but the only one who was really anti-Mia was Brook and YOU. John, Ami, and I had talked and we were all like no freaking way are we getting rid of Mia over Dolly or Lisa. That would be completely retarded. I thought she was perfect to take to the merge too because all the Choros were so agitated with her antics at Hot Tamale I thought the chance of them trying to align with her and her flipping on us were minimal. I have no idea what you came up with and told her, but the anti-Mia stuff was only for like the first two days we got here. After that, ALL of us wanted to keep her. Except Brook. And I thought you....

I'm still finding it hard to believe that Chris, who was a demanding mess since before the swap actually tried to make me out to be the bad guy when we GOT swapped. I was incredibly open and came clean about the alliance I had with John/Chad/Brook because it was fucking DONE. And if I had went pre-merge at the hands of Chris telling Mia I was like out to get her? That would have been too fucked up to even comprehend

Ami.... I'm really really confused about what Chris told Mia. I mean you are with me right? We thought CHRIS was against Mia and we were going to try to get him to understand it was not a good idea to vote her out. Or am I remembering this all incorrectly?

I know way way in the beginning... the first few days.... we were all anti-Mia cuz we thought she was scheming all over the place. But once we actually realized what was going on.... we knew we needed strong people to try to win challenges and Mia was definitely one of them. And John certainly didn't want her to go. He thought he had her wrapped around his finger. It was more me and you way in the beginning - like day 1 and 2 - but then we completely changed our tune and agreed that if anyone suggested it we were going to talk them out of it. And I don't think I ever even said a word to Chris that I had ever contemplated voting Mia out first. I think this was all Brook being a head case.

He was not the strategic leading force of nuGuatuso. He was an assclown. That we thought we could pick up because it was clear that everyone on Chorotega didn't like him. But it turned out he was a lying assclown.

What exactly did Gregg do during that challenge? Is he really color blind? Why didn't Caryn help him with it if he couldn't do it?

John was a total fucking trainwreck when he had to put the four puzzles together and we were all screaming at him JOHN GIVE UP YOUR LEADER ROLE so someone else could post it. We would have had it done in 30 minutes easily if he was listening to us.

I think it took a collective of 15-18 minutes for us four to post the pieces (Me, Chris, Brook then Chad)....THEN he took just over 30 minutes until he finally gave the leadership to me. That memory still upsets me.

I took a little less than 20 minutes. I was the last one. The entire challenge lasted 85 minutes. We got that question in an IC. It was 85 minutes.. So yea... it was really fucked.

He was not the strategic leading force of nuGuatuso. He was an assclown. That we thought we could pick up because it was clear that everyone on Chorotega didn't like him. But it turned out he was a lying assclown.


I was in 3 seperate alliances of the tribe and was always dictating the boots on NuGuatuso and was the only person never on the minority of the vote. Even after I had shown I was disloyal I created enough friction that even when I had become a trainwreck you and Brook and Ibe-Jolanda all never decided to just come together and vote me out at the f5.

You already said you would have voted Ibe out if Brook hadn't gone full retard. Stop trying to make yourself relevant.

Ami.... I'm really really confused about what Chris told Mia. I mean you are with me right? We thought CHRIS was against Mia and we were going to try to get him to understand it was not a good idea to vote her out. Or am I remembering this all incorrectly?

I know way way in the beginning... the first few days.... we were all anti-Mia cuz we thought she was scheming all over the place. But once we actually realized what was going on.... we knew we needed strong people to try to win challenges and Mia was definitely one of them. And John certainly didn't want her to go. He thought he had her wrapped around his finger. It was more me and you way in the beginning - like day 1 and 2 - but then we completely changed our tune and agreed that if anyone suggested it we were going to talk them out of it. And I don't think I ever even said a word to Chris that I had ever contemplated voting Mia out first. I think this was all Brook being a head case.

Oh without a doubt, you are 100% right. Chris was like screaming in caps that Mia needed to leave first over Julie. And it's like, that's him in a nutshell. Why on earth would anyone get rid of Mia over someone with 0 posts at the Arena board? He was crazy

The only reason I bandwaggond on the Mia hate train was to get closer to you. That was the first conversation you and I had that was truly about the game. Mere hours later The Motorboats were formed. Mia and I made an alliance in the first like 2 messages we sent to eachother, and I do remember telling you right off the bat because I thought it was fishy as hell. I guess in a small way I planted a seed against Mia with you and John, but it snow balled when you spread to everyone that she was targetting Brook. We all did think she was overplaying...but it would have been retarded to vote her out early, you're right about that.

Because Chris, Brook, Dolly and I were in an alliance, Brook very well could have turned Chris against Mia....but I wouldn't put the blame all on Brook.

He was not the strategic leading force of nuGuatuso. He was an assclown. That we thought we could pick up because it was clear that everyone on Chorotega didn't like him. But it turned out he was a lying assclown.


I was in 3 seperate alliances of the tribe and was always dictating the boots on NuGuatuso and was the only person never on the minority of the vote. Even after I had shown I was disloyal I created enough friction that even when I had become a trainwreck you and Brook and Ibe-Jolanda all never decided to just come together and vote me out at the f5.

You already said you would have voted Ibe out if Brook hadn't gone full retard. Stop trying to make yourself relevant.

Yeah at the f6 but Brook and me had a seperate deal and had we voted Ibe and 6 we would have voted you or John at 5. It wasn't the decision to vote John itself when he did it was the rash way he did it. Hell if Dolly had not quit we may have even taken you or him out when the tribe was down to 7.

Ami and Chad

Ami.... I'm really really confused about what Chris told Mia. I mean you are with me right? We thought CHRIS was against Mia and we were going to try to get him to understand it was not a good idea to vote her out. Or am I remembering this all incorrectly?

I know way way in the beginning... the first few days.... we were all anti-Mia cuz we thought she was scheming all over the place. But once we actually realized what was going on.... we knew we needed strong people to try to win challenges and Mia was definitely one of them. And John certainly didn't want her to go. He thought he had her wrapped around his finger. It was more me and you way in the beginning - like day 1 and 2 - but then we completely changed our tune and agreed that if anyone suggested it we were going to talk them out of it. And I don't think I ever even said a word to Chris that I had ever contemplated voting Mia out first. I think this was all Brook being a head case.

Oh without a doubt, you are 100% right. Chris was like screaming in caps that Mia needed to leave first over Julie. And it's like, that's him in a nutshell. Why on earth would anyone get rid of Mia over someone with 0 posts at the Arena board? He was crazy

The only reason I bandwaggond on the Mia hate train was to get closer to you. That was the first conversation you and I had that was truly about the game. Mere hours later The Motorboats were formed. Mia and I made an alliance in the first like 2 messages we sent to eachother, and I do remember telling you right off the bat because I thought it was fishy as hell. I guess in a small way I planted a seed against Mia with you and John, but it snow balled when you spread to everyone that she was targetting Brook. We all did think she was overplaying...but it would have been retarded to vote her out early, you're right about that.

Because Chris, Brook, Dolly and I were in an alliance, Brook very well could have turned Chris against Mia....but I wouldn't put the blame all on Brook.

The only ones I told that Mia wanted Brook out were you and John. And I did NOT tell Brook that. And yea we talked about the Mia alliance that we were really suspicious about because we didn't know if she was doing that with everyone else. But I never told Brook she was targeting him. I don't even think I had talked to Brook yet because it was like an hour into the game. But whatever craziness happened, I think Chris SERIOUSLY overplayed the Mia hate. It was definitely there in the beginning because the game was new and stuff, but after settling in.... we would have been the biggest dumbasses on the face of the planet to vote her off over Julie, Dolly, or Lisa. Ironically Lisa is sitting in the F3 right now. I'd really like to know what Chris told Mia because honestly the only thing I ever said to him was after she wanted to form our alliance of me, you, Chris, and her, and then she didn't respond to me about it for a whole day, I just said to Chris... "I don't know if that's actually real. I think she may have done this with everyone else." And then right before the second challenge I got a PM from Chris saying he wanted to work with you and I, but he didn't know about Mia because he didn't trust her. But apparently you guys were in a different alliance. I can't remember exactly, but I just remember you and I talking that we needed to talk Brook and Chris out of thinking booting Mia was a good idea. Which is rather ironic considering what Chris was apparently telling her.